So, 2013 X1 xDrive 281 - purchased 02/25/2013 w/20,000miles...now with a nail in passenger rear RFT, it is not holding the air. The dealer will replace tire, Pirelli 255/35 R 19 92 W. Someone told me or I read somewhere that all tires should be replaced. What is your advice? I bought the 5-year Tire and Wheel Protection. Is it ok to just replace one tire? I'm in the San Francisco Bay Area (yes, the earthquake woke up!), very mild weather. Let me know!
