Hi Rated,
I took of the driver side timing cover last August to double check my new alu vanos cover. Installed with a new metal gasket without touching the valve cover (no losening at al). No oil leeks so far so yes seems fine.
As not a massive job you may try the old gasket. If the car can stand still for a bit I'd order a new though to be on the safe side. I bought driebond but ended up not using it. The new gasket blue sealant did the job.
Ps. Timing cover bolts are 10nm (while valve cover 6nm).
Ps. Ps. Check my post from end August here:
https://www.m3post.com/forums/showth...038382&page=10